Editorial
Reviews
 |
From Publishers Weekly
An erudite, fascinating account by one of the foremost purveyors of contemporary
nonfiction, this book chronicles the underlying causes, utter devastation and
lasting effects of the cataclysmic 1883 eruption of the volcano island Krakatoa
in what is now Indonesia. Winchester (The
Professor and the Madman; The
Map That Changed the World)
once again demonstrates a keen knack
for balancing rich and often rigorous
historical detail with dramatic tension
and storytelling. Rather than start
with brimstone images of the fateful
event itself, Winchester takes a
broader approach, beginning with
his own viewing of the now peaceful
remains of the mountain for a second
time in a span of 25 years-and being
awed by how much it had grown in
that time. This nod to the earth's
ceaseless rejuvenation informs
the entire project, and Winchester
uses the first half of the text to
carefully explain the discovery and
methods of such geological theories
as continental drift and plate tectonics.
In this way, the vivid descriptions
of Krakatoa's destruction that follow
will resonate more completely with
readers, who will come to appreciate
the awesome powers that were churning
beneath the surface before it gave
way. And while Winchester graphically
illustrates, through eyewitness reports
and extant data, the human tragedy
and captivating scientific aftershocks
of the explosion, he is also clearly
intrigued with how it was "a demonstration
of the utterly confident way that the world, however badly it has been wounded,
picks itself up, continues to unfold its magic and its marvels, and sets itself
back on its endless trail of evolutionary progress yet again." His investigations
have produced a work that is relevant to scholars and intriguing to others,
who will relish it footnotes and all.
Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Amazon.com
It may seem a stretch to connect a volcanic eruption with civil and religious
unrest in Indonesia today, but Simon Winchester makes a compelling case. Krakatoa tells
the frightening tale of the biggest volcanic eruption in history using a blend
of gentle geology and narrative history. Krakatoa erupted at a time when technologies
like the telegraph were becoming commonplace and Asian trade routes were being
expanded by northern European companies. This bustling colonial backdrop provides
an effective canvas for the suspense leading up to August 27th, 1883, when the
nearby island of Krakatoa would violently vaporize. Winchester describes the
eruption through the eyes of its survivors, and readers will be as horrified
and mesmerized as eyewitnesses were as the death toll reached nearly 40,000 (almost
all of whom died from tsunamis generated by the unimaginably strong shock waves
of the eruption). Ships were thrown miles inshore, endless rains of hot ash engulfed
those towns not drowned by 100 foot waves, and vast rafts of pumice clogged the
hot sea. The explosion was heard thousands of miles away, and the eruption's
shock wave traveled around the world seven times. But the book's biggest surprise
is not the riveting catalog of the volcano's effects; rather, it is Winchester's
contention that the Dutch abandonment of their Indonesian colonies after the
disaster left local survivors to seek comfort in radical Islam, setting the stage
for a volatile future for the region. --Therese Littleton
From School Library Journal
Adult/High School-This expansive chronicle of a geologically unstable hot spot
between the islands of Java and Sumatra, scene of the cataclysmic 1883 eruption
of Krakatoa, conveys not only a wealth of scientific detail related to the event,
but also addresses long-term ramifications for the social, political, economic,
and religious fabric of the region. During the volcano's final 20 hours and 56
minutes, sounds from Krakatoa's eruption were heard 2968 miles away, and the
air shock waves it created were recorded circling the globe seven times. Ultimately,
the "six cubic miles of rock" that had been the island vanished. Winchester points
out that Krakatoa was the first catastrophe to occur "after the establishment
of a worldwide network of telegraph cables" that enabled news of the devastation
to be transmitted with heretofore unheard of speed. Scientific investigations
continue to this day, with particular watchfulness over Anak Krakatoa (literally, "son
of Krakatoa"), an active volcanic island located in the same spot, which began
forming in 1927-1930 and is growing in height at a rate of 20 feet per year.
The author cuts a broad swath as he transitions among topics as diverse as plate
tectonics, the 16th-century Dutch-colonial spice trade, and the seeds of radical
Islamic fundamentalism in Indonesia, but the telling is masterful and conscientious
readers are rewarded by his elucidation of complex interrelationships.
Lynn Nutwell, Fairfax City Regional Library,
Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Everyone's favorite geologist takes on a volcanic eruption that killed nearly
40,000 people and changed the climate for years.
Copyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From AudioFile
If you're looking for drama, you'll certainly find it here. With a volcanic
explosion heard 3,000 miles away and a related tsunami that killed close
to 40,000 people, there's plenty of excitement for the thrill-seeker. Win-chester,
author of the bestselling THE
PROFESSOR AND THE MADMAN, adroitly juggles
a plethora of subjects, from the Dutch spice trade in colonial Java to the
science of tectonic plates, creating a fascinating look at one of history's
most cataclysmic disasters. Despite his BBC tone, Winchester manages a dry
and ironic delivery, very much in keeping with his writing style. But the
main point of interest when the dust has settled is the far-flung ramifications
of this eruption upon world events. This is a winner. D.G. Winner of AudioFile
Earphones Award © AudioFile
2003, Portland, Maine-- Copyright © AudioFile, Portland, Maine
From
Booklist
*Starred Review* Winchester is a teacher to the world. Among his previous books
are the best-selling The Professor and the Madman (1998) and The
Map That Changed the World (2001), in which he taught us all about the Oxford
English Dictionary and the world's first geological map, respectively.
What's on his mind now? Sit back and learn, for this eloquent British writer
submits a fascinating account of the cataclysmic explosion of the East Indian
volcanic island of Krakatoa in 1883. The destruction was phenomenal, due primarily
to the sea waves created by the explosion-"the most violent explosion ever recorded
and experienced by modern man"-which swept away nearly 200 villages on neighboring
islands. Krakatoa evaporated, "blasted out of existence"-simply a space left
in the sea. Of course, this wouldn't be a book by Winchester if he simply narrated
the events of the eruption, exciting as the details are; no, he gives us a wealth
of further information, setting the incident within the contexts of general volcanic
behavior, plate tectonics, Dutch rule in the East Indies, and the region's flora
and fauna. In the wake of Krakatoa came the recognition that natural events in
one place can greatly affect those in far-distant places, hardly news to us but
news nonetheless back then. All readers, science-prone or not, will be delighted
by this experience-expanding book. Brad Hooper
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
|